That is why Magiq related to time is considered so dangerous, but let's not get out of control with our theorizing. Catastrophizing.
The bottom line for me is that I'm hearing protests with no solutions, and if it turns out that this is the correct one, morally and strategically, we are wasting time. And not every instance of messing with history involves a disaster.
Moreover, the Storm doesn't alter history, which is what we're talking about here. It just erases your memory and, it seems, erases you.
You are all 100% entitled to your fears and objections, they're valid. I understand them. But what alternative do you propose?
EDIT: As Rev said below, I want everyone to have their say and express their feelings on the situation. But I need..... alternatives. IF we're going to betray Sullivan's plan and his sacrifice, and forsake the 94 Mounties, I need a very good backup plan.